Insight

One atomic statement made by an expert, a student or a publication, with its evidence status.

Expert Open for expert review · What do these labels mean?

LCA from a bill of quantities takes roughly 50 hours and gives the best accuracy; a well-built BIM model (LOD 300 recommended) cuts that to around 20 hours; a simplified tool takes about 30 minutes with accuracy varying by roughly 10–20%. Garbage in a BIM model propagates straight into the result.

— Paraphrased from the lecture

Where in the source1:28:26–1:31:57 (LOD at 1:48:48) — anchor: “Bill of quantities takes about”
Confidencecheck — the accuracy range reads “2010 to 20%” in the transcript, and the simplified tool is first said to take about 10 minutes

Context

Julie Železná (UCEEB, CTU Prague) compares three ways of calculating a building’s LCA by effort and accuracy: from a bill of quantities, from a BIM model, and with a simplified tool like the one UCEEB built for the Czech Ministry of the Environment. The accuracy range of the simplified tool is garbled in the transcript (“2010 to 20%”), and she first says it takes about 10 minutes. The LOD 300 recommendation came up in the Q&A, when a student asked whether a less detailed model could still be used.

From the transcript

[…] the largest details you can get from bill of quantities. […] it takes a lot, a lot of time, but probably the result will be the best. […] another detail could be BIM model. […] this is really fast. It saves you like a third, 2/3 of time. But it must be done very well, the model I mean, because if you miss some items, if you miss some materials or it’s not well explained what it is actually, then the results miss it. […] And then there are several simplified tools. […] the quality of the result would vary […] about [10 to 20%, garbled in the transcript]. […] If you have [bill] of quantities, the LCA takes you about 50 hours. [With BIM] […] I think it’s even faster. It’s about […] 20 hours or maybe less if it works well. And with the simplified calculation tool, it’s about 30 minutes maybe if you are already used to the tool. — (Q&A) […] It’s like our recommendation because we work with some models already and we know that if there is not enough details, then […] you upload it to [the] LCA tool, you don’t have the details there as well. So you lose a lot of information and probably the calculation will not be as exact as it should be.

Automatic transcript, presentation, 01:28:26, and Q&A, 01:48:36. Lightly cleaned: repeated words and fillers removed, omissions marked […], editorial insertions in [brackets].

Connections


Something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction