Insight

One atomic statement made by an expert, a student or a publication, with its evidence status.

Expert Disputed · What do these labels mean?

From a 2013 World Green Building Council survey: a good outside view (park, greenery, river) raised mental function and memory by 10 to 25%, and calls were handled faster.

— Paraphrased from the lecture

Where in the source~00:29 — anchor: “good memory has risen from 10 to 25%“
Confidencecheck — see Part 6; the WorldGBC report does not publish these headline figures

Context

Petr Zahradník (EkoWATT) explains why investors certify buildings: the economic case rests on the occupants. He cites a 2013 indoor-environment survey by the World Green Building Council across many building types; the figures match the transcript, but the claim bank’s fact-check notes that the WorldGBC report does not publish these headline figures.

From the transcript

We talk about [the] indoor environment quality survey, which is quite old, was 2013, but it was a huge survey done by World Green Building Council in many building types, in the residential [buildings], hospitals, schools, office buildings. And here you can see that they found out that when you have good outside view, for example, in the park, greenery, river, mental function and good memory has risen from 10 to 25%. Calls were done much faster, so the people were in much better mood.

Automatic transcript, presentation, 00:28:36. Lightly cleaned: repeated words and fillers removed, omissions marked […], editorial insertions in [brackets].

What needs checking

A verification pass against public sources (claim bank, fact-check item 12) found:

Misattributed — the report does not make these claims. It deliberately avoids single headline productivity percentages. What it does give: view quality + daylight explain 6.5% of variation in sick leave; 4% performance drop at cooler and 6% at warmer temperatures; 8–11% productivity gains linked to air quality; “single digit improvements” from personal temperature control. The 40% retail figure is real but belongs to Heschong Mahone (1999) — skylit stores likely to have 40% higher sales (range 31–49%). The 18% and 23% figures do not appear. WorldGBC 2014 · Heschong Mahone

Transcription

The number or wording may have been garbled in the transcript, or the speaker hedged it (see Part 6; the WorldGBC report does not publish these headline figures). To be checked against the recording.

Connections


Something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction