Insight
One atomic statement made by an expert, a student or a publication, with its evidence status.
Expert Open for expert review · What do these labels mean?
Reuse and recycling do not automatically reduce carbon. A thesis on recycled aggregate found the resulting concrete had a higher footprint than concrete from raw materials; a wall built from recycled concrete may need more concrete than one from primary material.
— Paraphrased from the lecture
| Where in the source | Q&A 2:07:37–2:08:52 — anchor: “Sometimes it’s really worse” |
| Confidence | high |
Context
In the Q&A, a student designing a drone hub asked whether to reuse existing warehouse ‘big boxes’ or build a new cylindrical structure with lower operational carbon. After citing a renovation comparison, Julie Železná (UCEEB, CTU Prague) warns that reuse and recycling do not automatically lower the footprint.
From the transcript
But again, it [is] just one point of view. The circularity of the structures is also important. And saving the raw materials is also important. […] But in the carbon footprint, this can be tricky. It necessarily doesn’t mean that if you reuse you will save carbon footprint, or if you recycle you will save carbon footprint. It doesn’t work like that. Sometimes it’s really worse. For example, if you use some recycled aggregate, I saw some work, some thesis with recycled aggregate in concrete. Finally, the carbon footprint of the concrete was higher than if you use the raw materials. So it depends. […] the wall, if you build the wall from recycled concrete, maybe [you’ll] use actually more concrete than if you build it from the concrete from raw materials.
Automatic transcript, Q&A, 02:07:17. Lightly cleaned: repeated words and fillers removed, omissions marked […], editorial insertions in [brackets].
Connections
- Source: Logistics Development in the concept of certification and LCA
- Challenges: Embodied carbon of new and demolished warehouses
- Metrics: Material reuse share
Something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction