Insight
One atomic statement made by an expert, a student or a publication, with its evidence status.
Expert Open for expert review · What do these labels mean?
On a Copenhagen office, seventeen floor solutions were tested against weight, structural depth and carbon. Timber won on weight and carbon but lost on depth. The built answer used three systems in different zones.
— Paraphrased from the lecture
| Where in the source | ~1:24–1:27 — anchor: “we decided to look at them for weight” |
| Confidence | check — the transcript says “16 or 17” solutions, and the project name is garbled (“my mom Mullen”) |
Context
Still answering the question on common mistakes, Paul Astle (Ramboll) shows an office building in Copenhagen (its name is garbled in the transcript as ‘my mom Mullen’) where many floor solutions were compared on weight, structural depth and carbon. The transcript gives the number of options as ‘16 or 17’.
From the transcript
[…] it’s an office building in Copenhagen and when we looked at the floors, and as you know the floors are most important […] we did lots of analysis on different solutions and this is looking at 16 or 17 different solutions […] and we decided to look at them for weight, structural depth and carbon, because of course the carbon’s not the only driver. When we looked at weight, you can see that the timber solutions are pretty good […] When we look to structural depth, the timber are the worst […] and then when we looked at carbon, the timber did come out the best. But the actual solution to this project was not to use one of those, it’s to use three of them in different areas. […] It’s really about trying to use the right material in the right place and making sure we use all those opportunities to save carbon every step. But it’s never about one solution.
Automatic transcript, Q&A, 01:23:18. Lightly cleaned: repeated words and fillers removed, omissions marked […], editorial insertions in [brackets].
Transcription
The number or wording may have been garbled in the transcript, or the speaker hedged it (project name garbled). To be checked against the recording.
Connections
- Source: Net Zero That Holds Up – Whole-Life Carbon, Design Choices, and Delivery
- Challenges: Embodied carbon of new and demolished warehouses
- Metrics: Embodied carbon intensity
Something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction