Insight

One atomic statement made by an expert, a student or a publication, with its evidence status.

Expert Open for expert review · What do these labels mean?

On the Sugar Valley (former Siemens factory, Munich) master plan, protected endangered bats drove dedicated high-level bat homes and, crucially, the outdoor lighting scheme — the office’s lighting specialist calls himself an expert in “light and shadow design” so insects survive and bats aren’t killed at the lamps.

— Paraphrased from the lecture

Where in the source~01:32 — anchor: “there were bats on the site”
Confidencecheck — ‘insects’ reads ‘intact’ in the transcript, and ‘they don’t get killed in the lamps’ may refer to insects rather than bats

Context

A student from Munich asked about the Sugar Valley master plan on a former Siemens factory site and which techniques for integrating nature could help the students’ projects. Meisel explains how protected bats on the site were handled with a bat specialist and the office’s lighting designer. The transcript reads ‘enough intact’ where the claim bank reads ‘enough insects’, and it is not clear whether ‘they don’t get killed in the lamps’ refers to the bats or the insects.

From the transcript

For example, there were bats on the [site]. So […] it’s also a protected animal in Munich and Germany and it’s an endangered animal. So we needed to take special care of the bats and like making them have a good home on site in the new development […] — (01:32:14) And in this project especially we designed the [power, unclear in the transcript] for the [bats] so they get their new homes, that it will ensure that they have the best living conditions, and it’s relatively high, so they also fly relatively high […] So it’s very interesting because [it’s] very closely related to lighting, and how you light up your outdoor areas. So you bring also in the lighting design specialist, and the specialist that we have in the office always says I’m an expert on light and shadow design, because it’s very much also about not making it too bright so there’s enough [insects, ‘intact’ in the transcript] so they don’t get killed in the [lamps] and so on.

Automatic transcript, Q&A, 01:29:49 and 01:32:14. Lightly cleaned: repeated words and fillers removed, omissions marked […], editorial insertions in [brackets].

Transcription

The number or wording may have been garbled in the transcript, or the speaker hedged it (“enough intact” appears to be a transcription of “enough insects”). To be checked against the recording.

Connections


Something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction