Insight
One atomic statement made by an expert, a student or a publication, with its evidence status.
Expert Open for expert review · What do these labels mean?
Adaptability and disassembly extend service life and avoid demolition, which is where the big savings are — yet the standards currently do not permit modelling that benefit, partly because a claimed 100-year lifespan is easy greenwashing. The real driver is not material durability but moral service life.
— Paraphrased from the lecture
| Where in the source | Q&A 1:45:42–1:48:06 — anchor: “you demolish it because you don’t like it” |
| Confidence | check — the lifespan reads “103 years” in the transcript |
Context
In the Q&A after the LCA part, a student noted that logistics centres have long been adaptable and asked whether adaptability, being able to reuse the building, matters more in LCA than material choice. Julie Železná (UCEEB, CTU Prague) answers that it has a large impact but the standard does not currently allow it to be modelled. The lifespan in her brick-industry example reads “103 years” in the transcript.
From the transcript
[…] one thing is that you don’t see probably this scenario in your LCA calculations. You can model it […] If you have the adaptable space, you will probably have longer service life of the building. You will not demolish it. You will just renovate or something, maybe fit out. But regarding the standard, this is not allowed now. […] when you don’t rebuild the building, you don’t demolish and build a new one, then you save a lot of carbon footprint. So yes, adaptability has a large impact on it, but […] I don’t think that Europe has the way how to calculate it correctly, because you can also use it as green washing. You can say, OK, but my building is so good that it will last for [103, probably 100] years, which is for example the case of [Porotherm] or Wienerberger […] But it’s not about service life [of] the material. It’s about the […] moral service life of the building, because you demolish it not only because it’s in not good state, but you demolish it because you don’t like it anymore. You don’t need this space. So if you make it adaptable, then […] you higher the probability that the next user will still use it.
Automatic transcript, Q&A, 01:46:11. Lightly cleaned: repeated words and fillers removed, omissions marked […], editorial insertions in [brackets].
Connections
- Source: Logistics Development in the concept of certification and LCA
- Challenges: Buildings that change slower than logistics, Embodied carbon of new and demolished warehouses
- Metrics: Adaptability
Something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction