Domain · published

One of five thematic domains the studio worked in, synthesised from its student projects.

Number2
GroupModular
SummaryA logistics building is designed for change rather than for one tenant and one moment: it can shrink, grow, move, be taken apart and be used for something else, so its structure outlives the lease it was built for.
Statuspublished

Also known as: Domain 2 · Strategy 2

Principle

A logistics building is designed for change rather than for a single tenant at a single moment. Its structure, envelope and site are planned so that it can shrink and grow with demand, be reconfigured, moved, taken apart and given a second life — long life, loose fit.

Why it matters

Logistics changes faster than buildings: tenants, automation and delivery models turn over within years, and a hall that fits only one of them is demolished early (Adaptable and relocatable logistics structures). Logistics tenants typically sign leases of 5–7 years, while the building is expected to last far longer (Lease length is the hidden design brief). Inside those leases, occupiers deliberately keep slack — perhaps 50–70% utilisation for most of the year — so that they can reach full capacity before Christmas, which means buildings are sized and heated for an annual peak (Grey space – buildings sized for Black Friday).

The market is already sorting stock that can adapt from stock that cannot: in the Netherlands over 80% of vacant logistics space is second-hand, and retrofitting older sheds is often impractical (Old sheds are becoming unlettable). Every early demolition wastes the carbon already spent in the structure (Embodied carbon and adaptive reuse of logistics buildings).

Projects

Four student projects test the idea at four scales — a room that breathes, a building that travels, a structure that spans infrastructure and a wall made of reused containers.

  • Elsa Hauksdottir reworks a steel warehouse of about 11,000 m² in Reykjavík, built 14 m from apartment blocks, into an “elastic” building: movable partitions and foldable racks shrink the heated storage zone off-peak and free the rest for markets and exhibitions.
  • Amy Naprstek proposes a nomadic storage system of prefabricated, relocatable blocks in three sizes that combine storage with a temporary public programme; each configuration stays from 3–5 months up to 3 years, after which the plot returns to meadow.
  • Julia Kopác lifts modular warehouse, retail and crossing modules over highway cuttings on the edge of Prague, so the building acts as a noise barrier against traffic noise of up to about 75 dB and the ground is freed for greenery and footpaths.
  • Sara Sulollari adapts a port logistics building in Reykjavík with a courtyard extension and a U-shaped wind buffer built from 85 reused shipping containers that opens the waterfront to the public.

Key metrics

All values are as reported by the student; most are estimates or targets, and methods are documented in the linked case studies.

MetricValueSource
AdaptabilityReconfiguration in 2–4 h (manual partitions) vs 5–15 min (robotic); manual chosenElsa Hauksdottir
Adaptability60–120 days for selection, feasibility and design plus 4–20 days for site prep and assemblyAmy Naprstek
Design for disassembly score0 → 10 (qualitative rating)Amy Naprstek
Heating energy demand600,000 → 360,000 kWh/yr (conceptual estimate; the KPI chart shows 300,000)Elsa Hauksdottir
Publicly accessible area0 → up to 3,000 m² off-peakElsa Hauksdottir
Publicly accessible area0 → 1,850 m² of wind-sheltered public spaceSara Sulollari
Material reuse share0 → 85 reused shipping containersSara Sulollari
Pedestrian-level wind speed6.0 → 3.97 m/s in the sheltered zoneSara Sulollari
Embodied carbon intensity150 → 28 kgCO2e/m²Julia Kopác
Construction cost600 → 1,220 EUR/m²Julia Kopác
Noise level70 → 15 dB at the highway edge (method not stated; the proposal value looks implausibly low and needs checking)Julia Kopác
Impervious surface ratio47% → 4.9%Julia Kopác

For comparison, a lecture example of renovating rather than rebuilding an administrative building saved about 80% of the carbon, explicitly because the load-bearing structure was kept (Renovating an office saved about 80%).

Trade-offs

Evidence gaps

Expert insights

Regulatory observations

  • Current life-cycle standards do not allow designers to model the carbon benefit of adaptability and disassembly, partly to prevent unverifiable claims of very long service life (Adaptability saves carbon but can’t be counted). Where current standards limit the approach, its main benefit — avoided demolition — stays invisible in the assessment.
  • Without a material passport, each reclaimed element has to be certified individually before structural use, and insurers are cautious (Certification of reused structural elements is the real blocker); this applies to reused containers, relocatable blocks and second-hand halls alike.
  • Permitting is built around permanent buildings: expanding usually means a new planning process of two to three years (Expandable units are wanted but planning kills them), and the nomadic project caps each configuration at three years so that it can work as a temporary use (Amy Naprstek).
  • Iceland has no rules on pedestrian-level wind comfort, so the wind buffer was justified by the student’s own simulation rather than by a standard (Sara Sulollari).

Questions for practice

  • Developers: Could the grey space held for seasonal peaks be leased to public or civic uses off-peak, and how would that be written into the lease?
  • Designers: Which spans, clear heights and joints give enough flexibility without paying for flexibility no one will use — and how is that recorded so the building can later be taken apart?
  • Municipalities: Could a permit category for relocatable, time-limited logistics structures exist, with an obligation to return the land to its previous state?
  • Everyone: How could avoided demolition be credited in carbon assessment, so that a building designed for a second life is rewarded at the point of decision?

Connections


Something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction