Strategy · published
A repeatable evidence workflow from the student projects — which metrics to calculate, with which tool or method, and the decision it led to.
| Summary | A simple benchmark calculation compares the carbon of keeping and renovating an existing building with demolishing it and building new. |
| Tool or method | manual / formula (floor area × benchmark carbon intensity) |
| Status | published |
The question it answers
Does keeping the existing building save enough carbon to justify designing around it?
How it works
- Take the floor area of the existing building.
- Multiply it by a benchmark embodied-carbon intensity for renovation and for demolition plus new construction.
- Optionally add operational carbon and spread embodied carbon over an assumed lifespan, to compare per year.
- Keep the building if the saving is large, and design the new programme around its structure.
In the student projects
- Thomas Olsen — manual / formula. Embodied carbon saved by reuse: demolish + rebuild 1,566 tCO2e vs. renovation 450 tCO2e. Decision: “Keep and renovate the existing industrial structure instead of demolishing it, supported by the embodied carbon comparison (approx. 450 vs. 1,566 tCO2e).”
- Vladi Kostecki — manual / formula. Whole-life carbon: reconstruction 232.4 tCO2e/year vs. new build 745 tCO2e/year; Carbon per pallet handled: 1.45 kgCO2/pallet including embodied carbon. Decision: “Retain and reconstruct the existing industrial structure rather than build new, supported by the annualised carbon comparison (approx. 232 vs. 745 tCO2e/year).”
- Khrystyna Verbitska — manual / formula. Embodied carbon saved by reuse: approx. 210,000 kgCO2e saved by reuse, against 300,000 kgCO2e for new build. Decision: “Reuse an abandoned building on an inner-city brownfield instead of building new, which supports the embodied carbon saving and the green and public space gains.”
Values and decisions as reported by the student; see each case study for the page in the portfolio.
Where it falls short
- All three projects use benchmark intensities rather than an LCA of the actual building, so the result depends on the benchmark chosen.
- In Vladi Kostecki’s project the derivation of the 745 tCO2e/year for new build is not shown.
Where are the ambitions, metrics and tools?
They appear automatically below under Connections, and in Obsidian under the
auto_properties.
Connections
- Case studies: Thomas Olsen, Vladi Kostecki, Khrystyna Verbitska
- Metrics it calculates: Embodied carbon saved by reuse, Whole-life carbon, Operational carbon, Carbon per pallet handled
- Ambitions (through its projects): Cargo bikes and light electric vehicles, Fewer and cleaner last-mile trips, Green and productive roofs, Habitat and ecological connectivity, Logistics as part of the city, Micro-hub networks, Mixed use and function stacking, Multi-storey logistics, On-site renewable energy, Public access and community use, Reuse of existing buildings, Safe sites with separated flows
Something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction