Trade-off · published
A recurring conflict between two design aims or metrics, found in the student projects or reported by experts and publications, with how the projects handled it.
| Summary | Going vertical saves land but raises embodied carbon, construction cost and operational energy. |
| Status | published |
The conflict
Stacking logistics in height reduces the footprint and frees land. Taller structures need more material and more energy to run, so land use is traded against carbon and cost.
In the student projects
- Johannes Berger — Increasing warehouse height reduces area footprint (land use) but increases embodied carbon and CapEx (questionnaire; student says both extremes are developed).
- Johannes Berger — Building vertically lowers land use but raises operational energy cost (questionnaire Energy 2).
As reported by the student; see each case study for the page in the portfolio.
What experts and publications say
- A taller shed stores half as much again — Per the Ilora glossary, an 11 m (36 ft) clear height stores about 50% more pallets than 7.3 m (24 ft) on the same footprint.
- Height buys efficiency and buys a fire problem — Going taller improves automation efficiency but triggers in-rack sprinklers, ventilation and exhaust systems. Fire suppression is “super expensive”, so there is a trade-off.
- Over-build the height, don’t charge for it — When a tenant asks for 8 m clear height, Panattoni builds 10 m and absorbs the cost, because constraining height forecloses future uses.
Paraphrased from the lecture or publication; see each insight for its source and evidence status.
Connections
- Case studies: Johannes Berger
- Metrics in conflict: Land take, Embodied carbon intensity, Construction cost, Energy use intensity, Clear height, Structural utilisation, Visual impact on neighbours
- Expert insights: A taller shed stores half as much again, Height buys efficiency and buys a fire problem, Over-build the height, don’t charge for it
- Problem statements: Trade-offs across design and value
- Domains (through its projects): Micro-Hubs and Urban Mobility
- Ambitions (through its projects): Compact footprint, Drone and autonomous delivery, Efficient automated operations, Fewer and cleaner last-mile trips, Logistics as part of the city, Multi-storey logistics
Something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction