Insight
One atomic statement made by an expert, a student or a publication, with its evidence status.
Expert Open for expert review · What do these labels mean?
They don’t help with carbon, and on a single-storey large-span logistics roof the added mass would massively increase structure. They make sense where column centres are narrow or the building is already multi-storey. The reframing: if you double the structure to carry the roof, what habitat was destroyed to win that material?
— Paraphrased from the lecture
| Where in the source | 1:02:31–1:04 — anchor: “one of those difficult trade-offs we have” |
| Confidence | high |
Context
A student researching green roofs asked Paul Astle (Ramboll) how worthwhile they are for absorbing carbon on a logistics centre, together with planting trees around it. Astle calls it one of the difficult trade-offs of integrating biodiversity into buildings.
From the transcript
[…] inevitably to do that you actually need to support quite a lot of mass to make it work […] So if you had a logistics centre that has a single Storey and it has a large span roof, it’s probably not going to make sense overall in my opinion to use a green roof because you would massively increase the mass of that roof and at that kind of span that would really increase the structure that would be necessary […] But if you had a building where the column centres were quite narrow and you already had a multi-storey situation, then it might make more sense to have localised green roof areas […] But a green roof doesn’t really help with carbon. […] it’s a biodiversity investment. […] if we had to double the structure to support the green roof, then where has all that material come from and how much damage have we done to biodiversity to bring that material in?
Automatic transcript, Q&A, 01:02:31. Lightly cleaned: repeated words and fillers removed, omissions marked […], editorial insertions in [brackets].
Connections
- Source: Net Zero That Holds Up – Whole-Life Carbon, Design Choices, and Delivery
- Challenges: Habitat loss and cut ecological corridors
- Metrics: Green roof coverage, Structural utilisation, Biodiversity stress from materials
- Case studies: Ece Yasar
- Trade-offs: Green roofs against structure and carbon
Something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction