Trade-off · published
A recurring conflict between two design aims or metrics, found in the student projects or reported by experts and publications, with how the projects handled it.
| Summary | Green roofs and façades bring biodiversity and stormwater benefits, but their weight adds structure, cost and embodied carbon. |
| Status | published |
The conflict
Planted roofs and façades are a common way to give a logistics building ecological value. Their extra load has to be carried by the structure, which raises construction cost and embodied carbon, especially on large single-storey spans.
In the student projects
- Adam Večeřa — Adding green facades and roof (green roof/wall coverage, biodiversity) increases structural weight and therefore initial cost (CapEx) and may affect building operation (questionnaire).
- Elsa Hauksdottir — Maximising green roof coverage conflicts with minimising structural cost and embodied carbon (questionnaire).
As reported by the student; see each case study for the page in the portfolio.
What experts say
- Green roofs are a biodiversity investment, not a carbon one — They don’t help with carbon, and on a single-storey large-span logistics roof the added mass would massively increase structure. They make sense where column centres are narrow or the building is already multi-storey. The reframing: if you double the structure to carry the roof, what habitat was destroyed to win that material?
- Green roofs vs LCA — an admitted conflict — Putting nature on a roof adds substantial structural load, which worsens the carbon calculation; she names this as a genuine conflict.
Paraphrased from the lecture; see each insight for its source and evidence status.
Connections
- Case studies: Adam Večeřa, Elsa Hauksdottir
- Metrics in conflict: Green roof coverage, Biodiversity net gain, Embodied carbon intensity, Construction cost
- Expert insights: Green roofs are a biodiversity investment, not a carbon one, Green roofs vs LCA — an admitted conflict
- Domains (through its projects): Adaptive and Modular Logistics, Regenerative Peripheral Park
- Ambitions (through its projects): Access without a car, Adaptable over time, Compact footprint, Good neighbour, Green and productive roofs, Habitat and ecological connectivity, Logistics as part of the city, Low energy and water demand, Multi-storey logistics, Rainwater kept on site
Something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction