Problem statement · published

A system-level problem behind logistics architecture — how buildings are financed, leased, certified and valued — traced to the metrics, trade-offs and evidence in the knowledge base.

SummaryRating schemes and norms can be satisfied credit by credit without delivering what they were meant to achieve.
Evidence gapsNo tool checks whether a certification credit fulfils its intention.
Statuspublished

Also known as: Certificates can be met without meeting their intention

The problem

Certificates and norms can be met without fulfilling their intention. Design teams focus on achieving BREEAM credits rather than on the building as a whole, and the scheme tends to dictate design solutions instead of focusing on the intention behind them (Schweber & Haroglu (2014) – The impact of BREEAM on the design of buildings). Most rating schemes do not set biodiversity objectives at all (Evaluating biodiversity criteria in green building rating schemes).

The challenge notes carry a Common misreading section that shows the difference — see Habitat loss and cut ecological corridors and Designing for an unknown tenant.

What the evidence says

Each statement keeps its own source and evidence status; see Evidence status.

Connections


Something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction