Strategy · published
A repeatable evidence workflow from the student projects — which metrics to calculate, with which tool or method, and the decision it led to.
| Summary | A life-cycle assessment compares material or structural options for the same building, so the lower-carbon option can be chosen with numbers. |
| Tool or method | One Click LCA (life-cycle assessment software) |
| Status | published |
The question it answers
Which materials or structural system give the same building the lowest embodied carbon?
How it works
- Model the structure and envelope, or the existing building, as a bill of materials.
- Run a whole-life LCA (product stages A1–A3 and, where possible, the later life-cycle stages) for a baseline and for one or more alternatives.
- Read the result per m² and by life-cycle stage or resource type to see where the carbon sits.
- Choose the option with the lower embodied carbon, and check side effects such as cost or biodiversity stress.
In the student projects
- Lindsay Daphne Macuja — One Click LCA. Embodied carbon intensity: baseline 420 → proposal 354 kgCO2e/m² (Carbon Class B); Social cost of carbon 258,618 €. Decision: “The One Click LCA comparison supported choosing low-carbon concrete with 25% GGBS and 97% recycled steel reinforcement (420 → 354 kgCO2e/m², class B).”
- Ece Yasar — One Click LCA, with its Biodiversity Stress module. LCA of the existing cross-dock across stages A1–A5, with concrete, HVAC components and plastic membranes as the largest contributors; Biodiversity stress from materials: 7,920 PDF/m²/yr from materials.
- Sara Gani — a web LCA tool (probably One Click LCA, inferred from the graphics). Embodied carbon: current materials 800, proposed materials 520; Life-cycle impact by stage: A1–A3 materials dominate (GWP approx. 70%).
Values and decisions as reported by the student; see each case study for the page in the portfolio.
Where it falls short
- Aycha Chambashala names One Click LCA as the tool for comparing timber, steel and concrete, but shows no results.
- In Sara Gani’s project the calculation basis of the 800 → 520 comparison is not described.
- Only one project (Lindsay Daphne Macuja) shows a baseline-versus-proposal LCA that directly decided a material; Ece Yasar assesses the existing building only.
Where are the ambitions, metrics and tools?
They appear automatically below under Connections, and in Obsidian under the
auto_properties.
Connections
- Case studies: Lindsay Daphne Macuja, Ece Yasar, Sara Gani
- Metrics it calculates: Embodied carbon intensity, Social cost of carbon, Biodiversity stress from materials, Life-cycle impact by stage
- Tools: One Click LCA
- Ambitions (through its projects): Green and productive roofs, Habitat and ecological connectivity, Healthy workplaces, Logistics as part of the city, Low embodied carbon, Mixed use and function stacking, Open and connected edges, Public access and community use, Rainwater kept on site, Safe sites with separated flows
Something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction