Insight

One atomic statement made by an expert, a student or a publication, with its evidence status.

Expert Open for expert review · What do these labels mean?

Reusing an existing building saves upfront embodied carbon but often can’t reach modern operational performance; on a whole-life basis the reuse can come out higher. That flips again if the energy supply is renewable enough.

— Paraphrased from the lecture

Where in the source1:11:55–1:13 — anchor: “it could end up being higher”
Confidencehigh

Context

A student whose project converts abandoned buildings into data centres asked Paul Astle (Ramboll) why new build could be better than renovation for carbon. Astle explains the trade-off between upfront and operational carbon when reusing a building.

From the transcript

So using existing buildings is really good for embodied carbon because we don’t have to spend as much embodied carbon because we’ve already got the structure and all the walls and we can reuse those directly, which is great. The problem we have is that often it’s very difficult to make those existing buildings perform operationally at a level that we would expect today […] So what you can find, not always, but what you can find is that you can save carbon in your upfront [embodied] carbon, but if you look at a whole life carbon assessment by reusing that building, it could end up being higher. That though is also dependent on the carbon intensity of your energy. So if we were to say that that building had renewable energy, we might say, well, the carbon intensity of the renewable energy is so low it doesn’t matter that the energy efficiency is low as well […]

Automatic transcript, Q&A, 01:11:55. Lightly cleaned: repeated words and fillers removed, omissions marked […], editorial insertions in [brackets].

Connections


Something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction