Trade-off · published

A recurring conflict between two design aims or metrics, found in the student projects or reported by experts and publications, with how the projects handled it.

SummaryReusing an existing building saves upfront carbon, but if it cannot reach modern operational performance, whole-life carbon can end up higher.
Statuspublished

The conflict

Keeping a building avoids the embodied carbon of new construction. Upgrading it adds cost and embodied carbon of its own, and a reused building that runs less efficiently may lose over its whole life, particularly for energy-intensive uses such as data centres.

In the student projects

  • Vladi Kostecki — Reuse with an upgraded envelope and adaptive façade raises upfront cost and embodied carbon of the renovation but lowers operational energy and running costs (CapEx/embodied carbon vs. operational energy) (questionnaire 4.4).

As reported by the student; see each case study for the page in the portfolio.

What experts say

  • Reuse can lose on whole-life carbon — Reusing an existing building saves upfront embodied carbon but often can’t reach modern operational performance; on a whole-life basis the reuse can come out higher. That flips again if the energy supply is renewable enough.
  • Don’t force the wrong second life on a building — For data centres he would not compromise operational efficiency to reuse a shell: a 10%-less-efficient data centre likely loses over its life. His preferred move is relocation, not demolition — put the data centre elsewhere and give the existing building a use it suits.
  • In a data centre the embodied carbon is in the pipes — For a typical office, a bit more than half of embodied carbon sits in sub- and superstructure. For a data centre the building fabric is “not that big of a concern” — the mechanical, electrical and plumbing systems dominate, which means the levers sit with equipment manufacturers, not just architects.

Paraphrased from the lecture; see each insight for its source and evidence status.

Connections


Something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction