Trade-off · published
A recurring conflict between two design aims or metrics, found in the student projects or reported by experts and publications, with how the projects handled it.
| Summary | Light, movable and open envelopes give flexibility and low impact, but perform worse thermally and structurally. |
| Status | published |
The conflict
Relocatable blocks, inflatable envelopes and façades open to the public adapt easily and touch the site lightly. They insulate less, are less stable and add transport when moved, so flexibility is traded against thermal and structural performance.
In the student projects
- Amy Naprstek — Low thermal insulation of the lightweight relocatable blocks (thermal comfort, ability to store climate-sensitive goods) is traded against lower operational cost and lower embodied/operational carbon (questionnaire).
- Amy Naprstek — Relocatability and low site impact (area covered, biodiversity gain) come at the cost of truck transport emissions for moving the blocks, which the student has not yet quantified (questionnaire 4.4).
- Elsa Hauksdottir — An open façade for public permeability and daylight conflicts with the thermal performance needed in compact, closed logistics mode, so the façade switches between the two modes.
- Elsa Hauksdottir — A fully pneumatic envelope gives the most spatial flexibility, while a hybrid with only the roof inflatable trades some of that for structural stability.
As reported by the student; see each case study for the page in the portfolio.
Connections
- Case studies: Amy Naprstek, Elsa Hauksdottir
- Metrics in conflict: Thermal comfort, Heating energy demand, Adaptability, Operational carbon
- Domains (through its projects): Adaptive and Modular Logistics
- Ambitions (through its projects): Adaptable over time, Compact footprint, Design for disassembly and relocation, Good neighbour, Habitat and ecological connectivity, Lightweight structures, Logistics as part of the city, Low energy and water demand, Modular and prefabricated architecture
Something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction