Trade-off · published
A recurring conflict between two design aims or metrics, found in the student projects or reported by experts and publications, with how the projects handled it.
| Summary | Long spans, bridging structures and heavier loads give flexibility and free ground, but need more material, carbon and cost. |
| Status | published |
The conflict
Large column-free halls, buildings over infrastructure and rooftop uses all ask more of the structure. Every gain in span or load has to be paid for in material, which shows up as embodied carbon and construction cost.
In the student projects
- Adéla Berkovitz — Rooftop car parking would save land but needs heavier columns for the larger loads (structural material/embodied carbon), so parking stays on the ground (consultation).
- Robin Jesenský — A thicker copper shell (10 mm vs 5 mm) doubles copper mass and its embodied GWP, a choice the student lists without resolving.
- Julia Kopác — Cost to build roughly doubles (600 to 1,220 EUR/m²) in exchange for large gains in uninterrupted greenery, walkability, noise reduction and lower sealed-surface share.
- Julia Kopác — Choosing a vertical, above-ground scheme over an underground road option was driven by the embodied-carbon KPI, at the expense of a more complex long-span structure.
As reported by the student; see each case study for the page in the portfolio.
What experts say
- The biggest possible hall reflex is a carbon cost — Longer spans mean bigger beams; accepting shorter spans shrinks the structure. The level of flexibility built into a logistics building has to be balanced against it.
Paraphrased from the lecture; see each insight for its source and evidence status.
Connections
- Case studies: Adéla Berkovitz, Robin Jesenský, Julia Kopác
- Metrics in conflict: Structural utilisation, Embodied carbon intensity, Construction cost, Walkability, Noise level
- Expert insights: The biggest possible hall reflex is a carbon cost
- Domains (through its projects): Adaptive and Modular Logistics, Energy Symbiosis, Regenerative Peripheral Park
- Ambitions (through its projects): Compact footprint, Efficient truck flow and compact yards, Good neighbour, Green and productive roofs, Habitat and ecological connectivity, Low energy and water demand, Modular and prefabricated architecture, Open and connected edges, Rainwater kept on site, Safe sites with separated flows, Screening with greenery and façades
Something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction