Trade-off · published
A recurring conflict between two design aims or metrics, found in the student projects or reported by experts and publications, with how the projects handled it.
| Summary | Roof area and sunlight used for solar power are not available for green roofs, trees and shade, and the reverse. |
| Status | published |
The conflict
A roof can carry photovoltaics or planting, and a site can be open to the sun or shaded by trees. Projects that push renewable generation lose green and blue area, and projects that push canopy and green roofs lose solar access; some combine the two in a biosolar roof.
In the student projects
- Katrin Rybinskiy — Using the roof of data centre C for PV raises renewable energy generation but leaves no roof area for green roofs, so green and blue area must come from the ground plane.
- Thomas Olsen — Maximising green roof area improves stormwater retention, biodiversity and thermal performance but reduces roof area for PV and therefore renewable energy production (green roof coverage vs. solar energy yield); resolved with a combined biosolar roof (questionnaire).
- Julia Godard Lombard — Maximising solar panels improves energy supply but adds structural load and lowers biodiversity net gain (questionnaire).
- Marek Nový — Implied by the KPI table, not discussed by the student: solar exposure falls from 92% to 77% as tree count (46 → 257) and shaded public space (8% → 23%) rise, so more shade and canopy cost sun access (and possibly PV/daylight potential).
As reported by the student; see each case study for the page in the portfolio.
Connections
- Case studies: Katrin Rybinskiy, Thomas Olsen, Julia Godard Lombard, Marek Nový
- Metrics in conflict: Rooftop PV generation, On-site renewable energy share, Green roof coverage, Biodiversity net gain, Stormwater retention volume, Tree count and canopy cover, Sun exposure of outdoor space
- Domains (through its projects): Energy Symbiosis, Regenerative Peripheral Park, Urban Hybrid
- Ambitions (through its projects): Cargo bikes and light electric vehicles, Fewer and cleaner last-mile trips, Good neighbour, Green and productive roofs, Habitat and ecological connectivity, Logistics as part of the city, Low energy and water demand, Micro-hub networks, Mixed use and function stacking, Multi-storey logistics, On-site renewable energy, Public access and community use, Rainwater kept on site, Reuse of existing buildings, Shared waste heat
Something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction