Trade-off · published
A recurring conflict between two design aims or metrics, found in the student projects or reported by experts and publications, with how the projects handled it.
| Summary | Building below ground frees space and hides volume, but retaining walls and deep foundations raise embodied carbon and cost. |
| Status | published |
The conflict
Putting storage, parking or hubs underground keeps the ground free for green space and limits visual impact. Excavation and retaining structures are carbon- and cost-intensive, so the projects weigh hidden volume against a lighter above-ground scheme.
In the student projects
- Adam Večeřa — Going vertical frees ~120,000 m² of ground for park and ecology but requires deep underground storage and parking (−24 m), which conflicts with the embodied-carbon strategy ‘no underground / avoid deep foundations’ listed under KPI 2.3.
- Katrin Rybinskiy — Building underground would maximise green space and hide the volume but needs energy-intensive retaining walls, raising embodied CO2 and cost; building above ground is lower carbon but obstructs residents’ views (questionnaire).
- Roshni Basu — The courtyard/historic-centre concept gives deeper integration and social value but higher embodied carbon and CapEx because of underground construction, while the panelák concept is cheaper and has higher solar share (40–70% vs 20–40%) (questionnaire).
As reported by the student; see each case study for the page in the portfolio.
Connections
- Case studies: Adam Večeřa, Katrin Rybinskiy, Roshni Basu
- Metrics in conflict: Embodied carbon intensity, Construction cost, Visual impact on neighbours, On-site renewable energy share
- Domains (through its projects): Energy Symbiosis, Micro-Hubs and Urban Mobility, Regenerative Peripheral Park
- Ambitions (through its projects): Access without a car, Compact footprint, Fewer and cleaner last-mile trips, Good neighbour, Green and productive roofs, Habitat and ecological connectivity, Logistics as part of the city, Low energy and water demand, Micro-hub networks, Modular and prefabricated architecture, Multi-storey logistics, Public access and community use, Rainwater kept on site, Reuse of existing buildings, Shared waste heat
Something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction