Trade-off · published

A recurring conflict between two design aims or metrics, found in the student projects or reported by experts and publications, with how the projects handled it.

SummaryBuilding below ground frees space and hides volume, but retaining walls and deep foundations raise embodied carbon and cost.
Statuspublished

The conflict

Putting storage, parking or hubs underground keeps the ground free for green space and limits visual impact. Excavation and retaining structures are carbon- and cost-intensive, so the projects weigh hidden volume against a lighter above-ground scheme.

In the student projects

  • Adam Večeřa — Going vertical frees ~120,000 m² of ground for park and ecology but requires deep underground storage and parking (−24 m), which conflicts with the embodied-carbon strategy ‘no underground / avoid deep foundations’ listed under KPI 2.3.
  • Katrin Rybinskiy — Building underground would maximise green space and hide the volume but needs energy-intensive retaining walls, raising embodied CO2 and cost; building above ground is lower carbon but obstructs residents’ views (questionnaire).
  • Roshni Basu — The courtyard/historic-centre concept gives deeper integration and social value but higher embodied carbon and CapEx because of underground construction, while the panelák concept is cheaper and has higher solar share (40–70% vs 20–40%) (questionnaire).

As reported by the student; see each case study for the page in the portfolio.

Connections


Something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction