Trade-off · published
A recurring conflict between two design aims or metrics, found in the student projects or reported by experts and publications, with how the projects handled it.
| Summary | Automation saves labour and time but uses more energy, costs more to operate and can tie a building to one tenant. |
| Status | published |
The conflict
Conveyors, robotics and automated partitions make operations faster and less labour-intensive. They raise electricity use and operating cost, and a building tailored to one automated process may be hard to reuse.
In the student projects
- Hynek Hrabík — Adding conveyor belts and automation (needed for cargo continuity under the bays) raises energy consumption, conflicting with operational energy and carbon (questionnaire).
- Julia Kopác — Higher automation level (lower labour cost) increases electricity use, i.e. operating energy demand (questionnaire).
- Elsa Hauksdottir — Robotic partitions reconfigure much faster (5–15 min vs 2–4 h) and need less labour, but cost more to operate and have higher environmental impact than manual partitions.
As reported by the student; see each case study for the page in the portfolio.
What experts say
- Tailoring is a one-way door — Buildings can be tailor-made “to the point where it’s not usable for the future”, and with Amazon or H&M investing multiples of the building’s value in technology, the developer has no choice. Since the chance that another tenant uses such a building the same way after ~20 years is very limited, it must be possible to recycle it easily, ideally on site.
- 80% of the market need, not 100% of one tenant — The investor horizon is 15–20 years while leases run 5–10; a building must fit roughly 80% of market demand so tenants can be swapped without touching the asset’s fundamentals.
Paraphrased from the lecture; see each insight for its source and evidence status.
Connections
- Case studies: Hynek Hrabík, Julia Kopác, Elsa Hauksdottir
- Metrics in conflict: Level of automation, Energy use intensity, Operational carbon, Adaptability
- Expert insights: Tailoring is a one-way door, 80% of the market need, not 100% of one tenant
- Problem statements: Short investment horizon
- Domains (through its projects): Adaptive and Modular Logistics, Micro-Hubs and Urban Mobility
- Ambitions (through its projects): Adaptable over time, Compact footprint, Efficient truck flow and compact yards, Good neighbour, Habitat and ecological connectivity, Logistics as part of the city, Low energy and water demand, Modular and prefabricated architecture, Open and connected edges, Rainwater kept on site, Safe sites with separated flows
Something wrong or missing? Suggest a correction